ad38b943bb7478b12ca71fa95c5e642a.png

Barnes & Noble teeters in a post-text world

Barnes & Noble, that once proud anchor to many a suburban mall, is waning. It is not failing all at once, dropping like the savaged corpse of Toys “R” Us, but it also clear that its cultural moment has passed and only drastic measures can save it from joining Waldenbooks and Borders in the great, paper-smelling ark of our book-buying memory. I’m thinking about this because David Leonhardt at The New York Times calls for B&N to be saved. I doubt it can be.

First, there is the sheer weight of real estate and the inexorable slide away from print. B&N is no longer a place to buy books. It is a toy store with a bathroom and a cafe (and now a restaurant?), a spot where you’re more likely to find Han Solo bobbleheads than a Star Wars novel. The old joy of visiting a bookstore and finding a few magical books to drag home is fast being replicated by smaller bookstores where curation and provenance are still important while B&N pulls more and more titles. To wit:

But does all of this matter? Will the written word — what you’re reading right now — survive the next century? Is there any value in a book when VR and AR and other interfaces can recreate what amounts to the implicit value of writing? Why save B&N if writing is doomed?

Indulge me for a moment and then argue in comments. I’m positing that B&N’s failure is indicative of a move towards a post-text society, that AI and new media will redefine how we consume the world and the fact that we see more videos than text on our Facebook feed – ostensibly the world’s social nervous system – is indicative of this change.

First, some thoughts on writing versus film. In his book of essays, Distrust That Particular Flavor, William Gibson writes about the complexity and education and experience needed to consume various forms of media:

The book has been largely unchanged for centuries. Working in language expressed as a system of marks on a surface, I can induce extremely complex experiences, but only in an audience elaborately educated to experience this. This platform still possesses certain inherent advantages. I can, for instance, render interiority of character with an ease and specificity denied to a screenwriter.

But my audience must be literate, must know what prose fiction is and understand how one accesses it. This requires a complexly cultural education, and a certain socioeconomic basis. Not everyone is afforded the luxury of such an education.

But I remember being taken to my first film, either a Disney animation or a Disney nature documentary (I can’t recall which I saw first), and being overwhelmed by the steep yet almost instantaneous learning curve: In that hour, I learned to watch film.

This is a deeply important idea. First, we must appreciate that writing and film offer various value adds beyond linear storytelling. In the book, the writer can explore the inner space of the character, giving you an imagined world in which people are thinking, not just acting. Film — also a linear medium — offers a visual representation of a story and thoughts are inferred by dint of their humanity. We know a character’s inner life thanks to the emotion we infer from their face and body.

This is why, to a degree, the CGI human was so hard to make. Thanks to books, comics, and film we, as humans, were used to giving animals and enchanted things agency. Steamboat Willie mostly thought like us, we imagined, even though he was a mouse with big round ears. Fast-forward to the dawn of CGI humans — think Sid from Toy Story and his grotesque face — and then fly even further into the future Leia looking out over a space battle and mumbling “Hope” and you see the scope of achievement in CGI humans as well as the deep problems with representing humans digitally. A CGI car named Lightning McQueen acts and thinks like us while a CGI Leia looks slightly off. We cannot associate agency with fake humans, and that’s a problem.

Thus we needed books to give us that inner look, that frisson of discovery that we are missing in real life.

But soon — and we can argue that films like Infinity War prove this — there will be no uncanny valley. We will be unable to tell if a human on screen or in VR is real or fake and this allows for an interesting set of possibilities.

First, with VR and other tricks, we could see through a character’s eyes and even hear her thoughts. This interiority, as Gibson writes, is no longer found in the realm of text and is instead an added attraction to an already rich medium. Imagine hopping from character to character, the reactions and thoughts coming hot and heavy as they move through the action. Maybe the story isn’t linear. Maybe we make it up as we go along. Imagine the remix, the rebuild, the restructuring.

Gibson again:

This spreading, melting, flowing together of what once were distinct and separate media, that’s where I imagine we’re headed. Any linear narrative film, for instance, can serve as the armature for what we would think of as a virtual reality, but which Johnny X, eight-year-old end-point consumer, up the line, thinks of as how he looks at stuff. If he discovers, say, Steve McQueen in The Great Escape, he might idly pause to allow his avatar a freestyle Hong Kong kick-fest with the German guards in the prison camp. Just because he can. Because he’s always been able to. He doesn’t think about these things. He probably doesn’t fully understand that that hasn’t always been possible.

In this case B&N and the bookstore don’t need to exist at all. We get the depth of books with the vitality of film melded with the immersion of gaming. What about artisanal book lovers, you argue, they’ll keep things alive because they love the feel of books.

When that feel — the scent, the heft, the old book smell — can be simulated do we need to visit a bookstore? When Amazon and Netflix spend millions to explore new media and are sure to branch out into more immersive forms do you need to immerse yourself in To The Lighthouse? Do we really need the education we once had to gain in order to read a book?

We know that Amazon doesn’t care about books. They used books as a starting point to taking over e-commerce and, while the Kindle is the best system for e-books in existence, it is an afterthought compared to the rest of the business. In short, the champions of text barely support it.

Ultimately what I posit here depends on a number of changes coming all at once. We must all agree to fall headfirst into some share hallucination the replaces all other media. We must feel that that world is real enough for us to abandon our books.

It’s up to book lovers, then, to decide what they want. They have to support and pay for novels, non-fiction, and news. They have to visit small booksellers and keep demand for books alive. And they have to make it possible to exist as a writer. “Publishers are focusing on big-name writers. The number of professional authors has declined. The disappearance of Borders deprived dozens of communities of their only physical bookstore and led to a drop in book sales that looks permanent,” writes Leonhardt and he’s right. There is no upside for text slingers.

In the end perhaps we can’t save B&N. Maybe we let it collapse into a heap like so many before it. Or maybe we fight for a medium that is quickly losing cachet. Maybe we fight for books and ensure that just because the big guys on the block can’t make a bookstore work the rest of us don’t care. Maybe we tell the world that we just want to read.

I shudder to think what will happen if we don’t.

Read more: https://techcrunch.com/2018/05/07/barnes-noble-teeters-in-a-post-text-world/

4 thoughts on “Barnes & Noble teeters in a post-text world

  1. Clickbank Affiliates at a Glance Top Clickbank Affiliates Choices As a new affiliate marketer you wish to sell in a program that’s sold through a billing environment that’s totally secure. Many programs just request that you put in your nickname and it’ll generate your referral url for you. There are several pay-per-click programs online. What Does Clickbank Affiliates Mean? If you want to earn money with clickbank, visit us today. It is possible to also generate income from ClickBank by selling your very own digital products. The only means to genuinely make money is to receive in with a network like BreezeAds.com. By itself it will not earn money, obviously, but it’s a good too to have when marketers are interested in strategies to lessen workload and the time taken to set up online advertising and marketing campaigns. What you are going to learn will enable you to get started making money with Clickbank if you’re a beginner. Clickbank Affiliates Explained Finding the product approve from Clickbank isn’t so simpler. It also needs to be something which people want. If you’re interested in marketing digital goods on the web, the very best place you ought to look out for is the Clickbank. A History of Clickbank Affiliates Refuted Once you get your product set up and you recognize precisely how you would like to market it then you’re able to begin your Hubpage. On the opposite end of the scale you likewise don’t need to advertise a product with a gravity of under 10, unless it’s only new to the marketplace. There are a number of ways to advertise the Clickbank products and your internet advertising skills is going to be the key to how much online income you generate.

  2. Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your site and in accession capital to assert that I acquire actually enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I’ll be subscribing to your augment and even I achievement you access consistently fast.

  3. Quit Promoting LOW Paying Affiliate Sites We extract Cover Images and Banners of each CB product Amazon offers 4 percent commission, Ebay offers 5 dollar per referral Regrettably Clickbank provides only a limited number of tools, We review and REDEFINE the title and description of each CB product You could be earning up to 75 bucks on just a single sale. And platform for its affiliates to promote Clickbank products. Why should you listen to me? We IMPORT and UPDATE CB Marketplace automatically for you DAILY If you are indeed looking for a money making opportunity, We eliminate JUNK Domain Names and Expired CB products Clickbank XML feed information comes in XML format which is difficult to The earning potential with Clickbank products is virtually infinite. ClickBank is among the largest paying affiliate network system. We can say that XML feed is more meant for the programmers who can extract and process the data. While the typical commission of a Clickbank product is varied between 20 and 40 dollars, You can make TONS of Dollars every month, if you manage to sell 5 to 10 products a day. Clickbank offers almost 50 to 75 percent commissions on their At the same time, Clickbank.com provides a XML feed, We have the highest Google Page Rank of 5 You need to check out the amazing earning potential that Clickbank products can provide you with. Commission Junction offers 12 percent commission, Clickbank provides 50 to 75 percent Commission. Clickbank is among the largest affiliate network online today, Vendor’s product sales to their affiliates. And it pays millions of dollars to its affiliates each year. The earning potential with Clickbank products is virtually limitless. When you market products from Clickbank, Just imagine, 50 to 75 percent as commission on sales to all affiliates — Is not that amazing? Of each item, which are listed for sale at Clickbank Marketplace. Understand for novice Clickbank affiliate members. Sign Up Today, to receive your very own profitable business in less then 30 seconds. That is easy and will help you sustain a Wonderful life, We’ve been ONLINE since 2006 Which Includes the list of products along with the name and description Please check out the commissions offered by the significant opponents of Clickbank®. https://lewisenterprises.leadprimo.com/real-success

  4. Just quit Promoting LOW Paying Affiliate Sites Vendor’s product sales to their affiliates. Which Includes the list of products along with the title and description We IMPORT and UPDATE CB Marketplace automatically for you DAILY Clickbank is one of the largest affiliate network online today, You could be earning up to 75 bucks on just one single sale. Commission Junction offers 12 percent commission, Clickbank offers 50 to 75 percent Commission. When you promote products from Clickbank, Just imagine, 50 to 75 percent as commission on sales to all affiliates — Is not that amazing? We review and REDEFINE the name and description of each CB product Amazon offers 4 percent commission, Ebay provides 5 dollar per referral Sign Up Today, to receive your own profitable business in less then 30 minutes. We have been ONLINE since 2006 The earning potential with Clickbank products is virtually limitless. At the same time, Clickbank.com provides a XML feed, Clickbank XML feed data comes in XML format which is difficult to Clickbank offers almost 50 to 75 percent commissions on their Of each product, that are listed for sale at Clickbank Marketplace. You could make TONS of Dollars every month, if you are able to sell 5 to 10 products every day. ClickBank is among the largest paying affiliate network system. We extract Cover Images and Banners of every CB product We can say that XML feed is more meant for the developers who can extract and process the data. We now have the highest Google Page Rank of 5 And it pays millions of dollars to its own affiliates each year. Why should you listen to me? The earning potential with Clickbank products is virtually infinite. You need to check out the amazing earning potential that Clickbank products can offer you. And platform for its affiliates to promote Clickbank products. While the typical commission of a Clickbank product is varied between 20 and 40 dollars, We eliminate JUNK Domain and Expired CB Solutions If you are really looking for a money making opportunity, That is simple and will help you sustain a great life, Please take a look at the commissions offered by the significant opponents of Clickbank®. Understand for novice Clickbank affiliate members. Unfortunately Clickbank provides only a limited number of resources, https://goo.gl/G1fzC1

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.